The Game is On
We're now a few days into 2004. Here's what's going on:
First, the Man gave me a huge sparkley ring with a bunch of diamonds on it on Christmas Eve. I keep taking it on and off. We've agreed to not even consider taking any additional steps until Dec 2004, thankfully. I had seriously, gravely underestimated the happiness this ring would bring to my parents and the Man's family- its clear to me that if we are going to get married, it won't be a simple trip to the courthouse, as we'd planned. I can't do that to my family.
So, if we're not going to get married before the Man starts treatment, the major "pro" on my reasoning list is removed. There are still a few items on that side of the list, including "future building" and "kids". However, we can build our future together without getting married, and I see no reason to get married until we actually have kids.
If I had any doubts on whether or not I really did want to get married, they have cleared up: I don't. I feel awful about everything. I feel like I set the Man up. He does want to get married. People are already giving us engagement presents. This is insane.
The Man said that it was okay if we stayed engaged for a decade, forever, it didn't matter: "You can't force someone to love you, to want to marry you."
This is wrong on two counts. First, if a person really does want to get married, then s/he is not going to be happy in a relationship where marriage is not an option. It's not a fair situation. No one worth their salt would tell an unhappily single girlfriend to stick it out with a man who clearly doesn't ever want to get married, and surely the same applies here. Second, it mistakes love for wanting to get married. I will happily commit to the Man in a ceremony of our own making. I just don't want to become a "wife" or a "Mrs." I pointed out to the Man that getting married changes very little for him; everything changes for me. Now clearly that is an exaggeration, but only somewhat. His name doesn't change, his identity doesn't change.
However, basically my argument boils down to a very strong negative gut feeling towards getting married, and a battle over semantics. No matter what, I create my own identity, and the reasonable side of me knows this. I can stick to "Ms" if I want, and I can keep my name. However, I can't get around this extremely strong almost hatred I have towards the idea of getting married.
However again, clearly there is some ambivalence. After all, I did say "yes." Worse, we have spent several months now talking about whether or not we should get married, and in a cold analysis I agreed that it would be to our benefit to do so.
Mainly, if there were no ambivalence, I would just change my mind and say no. I haven't gotten there yet, either. I have removed the ring several times, and frequently switch it from my left to right hand, then back again. But the Man gave me this ring as a contract, not as decoration, so I don't do this often and never in his sight. I only feel marginally better with the ring off. I don't want to throw away this relationship, either.
Either way, a line has been crossed. To take the ring off and state my intention to remain unmarried will hurt the Man emotionally and will also hurt his pride, as it will be announced to family and friends after the intent to get married was already made. It will also make me look unstable, but at this point that's a truism, actually. I certainly feel miserable and fluctuating and unstable, nauseous and tearful. Unless I can get my head and heart around it, to continue on with plans to get married is to continue this fucking awful state of depression and neuroticism, unbalanced.
While the Man helpfully states that it's okay if we don't get married, that we can stay engaged permanently, I don't think that this will actually play out. He's said it, and you can see it, that he really does want to be married. It's a state that he wants to experience. This is the norm, and I wouldn't want him to not have that experience if he wants it, even if it can't be with me. I don't exactly want him to have it with someone else, either.
So the first challenge then is to determine whether it's better to honor this gut feeling of mine, or to identify it as something that is getting in my way and work to dismantle it.
Maybe I need to read up on Erik Erickson. I'm surprised that it hasn't occurred to me earlier, but this certainly feels like I'm in the middle of his "intimacy" crisis, although I'm a few years behind. All I really know is that if this ambivalent state lasts much longer, bad things will occur. I'm crying every day and ready to vomit most of the time, in a nasty state of depression and anxiety. I am not usually like this at all. Also, there are periods when I forget it and get back to my usual pleased, contented self, then remember and swing back into sadness. Hence the unbalanced sense.
The only positive coming out of this is that my instinct is to move towards the Man. As noted earlier, we've agreed to not make any plans at all for a year. We will go through treatment and some time afterwards, so he can recover from treatment. We'll talk again about getting married in December 2004, earlier if treatment makes it necessary. I'll have to come to a decision long before Dec 2004, but will then have a long time to adjust myself. If I can't get my head and heart around getting married, then we'll have had a long cooling off period before telling everyone that we're not getting married after all. If I do come to some peace about getting married, then we'll have a period of relative quiet to enjoy before entering into the insanity of planning to get married. (Ick. If we do it at all, I'm leaving it up to my mom and his mom).
It should be noted that I'm figuring this out as I'm writing it. This is my way to peace. The Man might need something else. I've kept my ambivalence mostly to myself, but not all of it, as it's important to both of us. He might prefer resolution differently, although he appears to be settled on the outcome. He pointed out that I did something similar before agreeing to move in with him, and we both agree that it was the best decision. He thinks that we should just get married, and that after it's over with I'll come to the same agreement with him that it was the best decision. I don't know that moving in together and getting married are on the same level of importance, although technically you can get out of both arrangements. He strongly feels that my negative emotions are in part generated by the intense attention and questioning on the part of everyone else. He's pretty overwhelmed by it, also. Although, part of what brought us together was that neither one of us wanted to get married, and so we didn't feel pressure from the other regarding the direction of our relationship.
As with everything, I guess we'll see. If it was just me and the Man, things would be okay. Sometimes I wish I were normal like everyone else, who wants to get married and are happy about such things. Hm. To thine own self be true, eh?